Trade ins & Orders
If you have a card request or a game request, we are here for you! Select the form of your choosing below and fill out the details of your order. Once we have fulfilled your order, you will receive a confirmation email from us, and you can come pick up your order in store!
You may submit as many requests as you would like. Card orders over $20 will ship for free. All other orders will receive free shipping on orders over $75. Click on one of the two order request buttons below to begin your order! Any questions feel free to call Firefly Toys & Games at 803-996-3473 or email us at email@example.com
Looking to change up your hobby? Want to upgrade some things in your game, but need a little help? Bring in cards from Magic: The Gathering or those old video games you haven't played in so long for some cash or credit!
WHAT CAN I TRADE IN?
We take in Magic: The Gathering, Pokémon, and Yugioh cards that are valued at $2.00 and up, video games and systems, and miniatures.
Note: We reserve the right to decline purchasing any or all of a collection for any reason.
HOW MUCH CAN I BRING? HOW LONG DOES IT TAKE?
You can bring small or large collections! The speed at which we get through collections depend on a number of factors. We aim to have all collections done in a timely manner. Collections can take up to seven (7) days to evaluate, depending on various factors. For some collections, we have specific people that are needed to evaluate them. You may be asked to leave your items with us to be evaluated by knowledgeable employees.
We have paperwork that you will fill out regardless of if you leave the collection with us or not. This paperwork will have your contact information on it so we can get in touch with you once the collection evaluation process has been completed.
DO YOU OFFER STORE CREDIT OR CASH, AND IF SO, HOW MUCH WILL I GET?
We offer card credit, store credit, and cash. What you get back will depend on what you sell and what you are looking for. See the break-down below:
Selling Trading Cards (Magic: The Gathering, Pokémon, and Yugioh)
Card Credit*- 50% of the value in credit for other singles that are in our store.
Store Credit- 40% of the value in credit that is good for anything in our store that we sell.
Cash- 30% of the value in cash. For larger collections, we may issue a check instead of cash.
For cards that are over $70 in value, there is an added 10% bonus to each of these sections.
*Card Credit can only be received through trading in Magic: The Gathering, Pokémon, and Yugioh cards.
Selling Video Games and Consoles
Store Credit - 40% of a game's value; 50% of a console's value.
Cash - 30% of a game's value; 40% of a console's value.
Store Credit - 25% of the miniature's value
Cash - 15% of the miniature's value
HOW DO YOU PRICE THE CARDS?
Magic: The Gathering and Yugioh:
We use TCG Player's listed median price. (This is the gray price on the right of their page when looking up a card.) This price is the most stable price for us and reflects the median price of the cards listed on the site at any given time. It is extremely reliable as a baseline price. We also look at the card's condition, which could alter the price we place on a card.
For high end cards, we may cross-reference eBay or other online retailers.
We use TrollandToad.com to price Pokémon cards; it is one of the most stable markets on the internet. We look at the seller (Troll and Toad) for pricing cards. Pokémon cards must be in near-mint condition and over $2.00 in value. We may cross-reference eBay or other online retailers.
For high end cards, we reserve the right to decline accepting the cards.
HOW DO YOU PRICE THE VIDEO GAMES?
We take all kinds of video games and consoles that are in working order. Consoles need to have the power cable and the AV (audio/video) cable, along with a working controller at the time of trade-in. In order to get the highest amount back for a trade-in, you need to have all of these items with you. Games should be in decent condition, and not have excessive damage or wear. We only buy and sell used games and game systems. Occasionally, we may take in new-in-box (NIB) items, but this is on a case-by-case basis.
We use several different online selling outlets in order to keep up with modern trends on pricing for systems and games. We strive to be as competitive as possible with our trade-in values as well as our prices on items currently for sale in our store.
HOW DO YOU PRICE THE MINIATURES?
We only take fully assembled and complete miniature models (nothing loose or have fallen off) or complete-in-box (CIB) miniatures. The miniatures can be painted or unpainted.
We use several different online selling outlets, including the sold listings on eBay, in order to keep up with modern trends on pricing for miniatures. We strive to be as competitive as possible with our trade-in values as well as our prices on items currently for sale in our store.
All trade-ins require a valid government issued ID and for some paperwork to be filled out. This is to protect both Firefly Toys & Games and You, the customer.